• On November 28, 2025, Vodafone filed a preventive legal protection with the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf, aiming to stop the Federal Cartel Office from making a decision in Vantage Towers-1&1 dispute: https://forum.investmentwiki.org/t/1-1-news/152/103?u=aron

  • Vodafone speculates that Federal Cartel Office’s head, Andreas Mundt, wants to use the proceedings to help 1&1 achieve faster rollout of its network: https://forum.investmentwiki.org/t/1-1-news/152/103?u=aron

  • Vodafone accuses the Federal Cartel Office of allowing 1&1 to control the proceedings, a claim that both 1&1 and the Federal Cartel Office deny: https://forum.investmentwiki.org/t/1-1-news/152/103?u=aron

  • Vodafone’s application for preventive legal protection has been described as unusual since the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf (OLG Düsseldorf) normally sets a high bar for granting it.

    “Furthermore, a preventive injunction is only admissible if the affected party can assert that the intended publication of the prohibition order without the redactions requested by him would result in reparable or at least difficult-to-compensate disadvantages for him,” Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf wrote in a 2015 ruling.

  • According to Tagesspiegel Background, complaints against the Federal Cartel Office (FCO) are not relevant under anti-trust law.

  • Tagesspiegel Background noted that Vodafone relied on a recent Lufthansa/Condor ruling, in which the OLG Düsseldorf ruled against the FCO after expressing concerns about possible “bias” at the authority.

    “Secondly, the contested order of the Federal Cartel Office is formally unlawful and must therefore be overturned because the members of the decision-making division have given rise to concerns about bias. This stems in particular from the fact that, during a review of the files, Lufthansa was sent a different version of an original memorandum,” OLG Düsseldorf wrote in its ruling.

  • Tagesspiegel Background also said Vodafone pointed to several files about the proceedings from the FCO that have been redacted.

  • The timeline of the ruling usually takes several months:

    • The FCO announced in August 29, 2022 that Lufthansa had violated antitrust law. OLG Düsseldorf suspended the decision in May 10, 2024 and made a ruling in August 20, 2025.
    • In August 2019, OLG Düsseldorf suspended a decision by the FCO in February 2019. However, this case was fast-tracked.
    • Adobe challenged the FCO cost decision before the OLG Düsseldorf in 2024; the OLG ruled on 26 February 2025.
  • A recent study (study period: May 2004 to April 2021) by Podszun/Robertson on judicial review of the FCO finds that at the OLG Düsseldorf level, about 26% of complaints are fully dismissed while 13% are fully annulled.